Showing posts with label book club. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book club. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Connecting with "Mrs. Bridge"

The Fab 5 met tonight to discuss and dissect the life and times of Mrs. Bridge, the subject of the novel by the same name by Evan S. Connell published in 1959. This choice was my doing; I’ve been interested in reading the book for quite a while. Many years ago there was a Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward made-for-TV miniseries called Mr. and Mrs. Bridge (see photo to the right), based on this book and its companion, Mr. Bridge. I don’t remember being bowled over by it, other than I enjoyed seeing them act together, but I always wondered what the big deal was about the book. Since I’ve owned the book forever but haven’t taken time to read it, as I am wont to do I brought it to book club to inflict it on them so that I would read it too.

Mrs. Bridge is the wife of a wealthy lawyer and the mother of three children living the country club life in Kansas City just before World War II. Time is passing her by—her kids are getting older, the world is changing around her, but she stays just the same.

Tentative and polite to a fault, Mrs. Bridge (her real name is India, but she’s never felt it fits) has a complicated inner life, a life of quiet desperation, which rarely makes its way out of her brain. While she wishes to improve herself, she never can quite finish her projects--learning Spanish, doing charity work, improving her vocabulary.

World issues, politics, philosophy, art…all of these things interest her a bit, but she doesn’t feel qualified to offer opinions on any of them. She defers to her husband’s opinions, as well as his wishes on just about everything. She is uncomfortable with anything different, which includes people different from herself. Anyone of any noticeable ethnicity seems to be disturbing to her, in a ethnocentricity that goes beyond black/white race relations of the time.

She would’ve been a little concerned at the way we attacked the Mexican food we had for dinner. Far too ethnic, I think, and who knows what rules of good manners we were breaking, dipping our chips into take-out bowls of queso.

Mrs. Bridge is lonely and bored. She has everything she could ever want, including a maid to do all the domestic chores, but she has no one to feel really close to. Her husband works all hours to provide all the material goods they could want, but he offers no real companionship. Her children are rapidly outgrowing their desire to be anywhere near their old-fashioned and oddly unworldly mother. She has very limited ideas of everything, from manners to sexuality. When a friend commits suicide, she tells her grown children that the woman had eaten some tuna that had been left out overnight. When a cousin has a baby three months after her wedding, Mrs. Bridge mentions that first babies are so often premature. Since “appearances” are all that really matter to her, she never faces most of reality.

Sonya was so caught up in Mrs. Bridge that she immediately went out to buy Mr. Bridge and read it too. But of course we wouldn’t let her tell us about it, because we might read it too. Which made discussion rather difficult for poor Sonya tonight, because she couldn’t possibly discuss the book as if she were uninformed of Mr. Bridge’s side of the story.

We debated if Mrs. Bridge’s inability to do anything is because she is a product of her time or because her husband’s dismissive attitude made her to hesitant to make a move. In the end, though, it’s hard for a millennial woman to understand her. On the other hand, there are some very universal things, like the distance she feels from her children as they become independent adults. Or her fears about how the future is dark, that the world might just fall apart around her.

Connell’s writing is very unusual. Each chapter is a tiny scene in Mrs. Bridge’s life, and, especially in the beginning, it’s difficult to see where it might be going. But eventually all of these vignettes weave into a full portrait of a woman living half a life. He describes things so well. At one point, she has read a political book and decides she will vote differently this time around. She never gets around to talking to Mr. Bridge about the book, so she figures that for once they will each vote their own way. But on the way, she starts to feel doubtful about her choice. “And when the moment finally came she pulled the lever recording her wish for the world to remain as it was.”

While she is floundering in boredom and desperation, we wonder what her problem is. Why not take classes, or volunteer, or take over the baking, or whatever? A long time ago we read I Don’t Know How She Does It, which was the opposite—a woman who was killing herself “having it all”—children, husband, career. We’re looking for a happy medium—not too busy, not too leisurely. We can only hope our stories will end more happily!

Monday, October 28, 2013

The Lifeboat: Save It or Throw It Overboard?

Well, after an unintentional year-long sabbatical, thought it might be time to get back at it. I have no excuse to offer as to why I’ve stopped blogging; I haven’t stopped reading!

The Fab 5 Book Club has not stopped reading either. Tonight we tackled The Lifeboat by Charlotte Rogan. Before we get started, you need to understand that the Fab 5, while being a very chatty crowd, does not always stay on topic very well. Also you need to understand that we don’t all always come terribly prepared.

Tonight was a different story. Everyone had finished the book, even the one who started it last night at 5 and finished it around midnight (Hint: This was not me, at least not this time). It’s a fairly quick read, which is always helpful in last-minute cramming. And Nancy was very eager to get started, trying to come up with some less-than-obvious segues from the food we were noshing to the plot of the book, things like “I bet they wished they had cheese like this on the lifeboat.”

And finally we gave in and actually talked about the book. The Lifeboat is a story about just what it sounds like, a lifeboat. The Empress Alexandra, a fictional ocean liner crossing the Atlantic just 2 years after the Titanic disaster, sinks in open water, and passengers scramble to get onto lifeboats. Grace, a new bride, is pushed onto a lifeboat by her husband, and the story begins. Thirty-nine people set off in a lifeboat, only to be lost at sea for 21 grueling days.

At the start of the book, Grace has survived the lifeboat and now finds herself facing a new obstacle: she is standing trial. She writes a diary of her experiences for her lawyers.
Grace is an enigmatic character, presenting readers with lots of ethical and moral questions. But while this might seem to be a book based on the old ethics question of the lifeboat—a lifeboat has too many people, so you must find a rational way to decide who should go overboard—it really turns out to be something different. As Grace goes through the process of recollection, trying to bring to the surface moments that she cannot easily remember, readers find no easy understanding of her fellow passengers’ actions. Nor can we get a handle on Grace herself. So rather than asking what we would do in their situation, we spent a lot of time trying to understand who did what and why.
Interestingly, three of the four of us read this book with one or two other stories in the back of our minds, influencing what we read. Sonya had the movie Titanic in her head, which made her suspicious of Grace’s husband’s actions before the boat sank. Nancy couldn’t help but think of our recent read Gone Girl, in which a woman’s diary takes on a different significance as the book goes on. I had shadows of Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace, in which the main character has been accused of murder but you really have no idea if she is guilty or not, or what guilt even means. Also Life of Pi loomed large in the lifeboat imagination.
This may be the longest period of time we’ve ever spent talking about a book at book club, which is all the more surprising since each of us expressed some degree of disappointment with the book. There are many, many threads and clues—or red herrings, as the case may be—that lead us nowhere, and none of us were terribly satisfied with that. Grace says straight out that we can’t know everything, but that did nothing to quell our dissatisfaction. We spent a bit of time talking about whether a book (or other form of entertainment) should tie up most or all loose ends, or if that is also unsatisfying. It seems there is some middle ground, Chekhov’s gun notwithstanding.
It may be that my own dissatisfaction with the ending had less to do with the book itself and more to do with the fact that I was reading it electronically, and the end came even though there were still 30 more digital pages to go—acknowledgements, suggested reading, endorsements, reading group guide, etc. etc. And here I thought there was still more to the story.
Of course we did get a bit off topic, debating which people we might be okay with pushing overboard and discussing the fact that all of us would probably die within the first few days because we are, well, soft. Barbara mentioned the day that she had a paper cut on the tip of her finger, and her day was an anguish of alternating between typing with a band-aid on, which made for many typing errors, and typing without a band-aid, which “really hurt.” I scoffed at the idea of needing a trailer to go camping, then remembered that the threat of a rainstorm sends me from my tent to the nearest hotel. Don’t think any of us would do too well in boot camp, let alone any real human deprivation.
But no deprivation was happening here, as we passed around the dark chocolate sea salt caramels. Final judgment: The Lifeboat had some saving graces, but you don't really want to stay in it forever.

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Saving Lives and Eating Apple Crisp


How do you grieve the loss of a loved one? In How to Save a Life, a young adult novel by Sara Zarr, high school senior Jill is mourning the recent loss of her father. But her immediate problem is that her mother has decided to adopt a baby from a pregnant teen they’ve never met. And that teen is coming to live with them.
Eleven Neland ladies showed up tonight to talk about it. Everyone had opinions, and they were not always in agreement. That’s the sign of a good book club discussion! Some of us liked Jill; some of us didn’t. Some of us liked Mandy, the pregnant teen; some of us didn’t. Some of us found different circumstances realistic; some of us didn’t. But we all agreed that the book draws you in from the first page, and you need to know what happens. And Helen didn’t even read the end ahead of time, which I think was high praise.

Mandy is the product of a sad upbringing, and she has some quirks. One of the disagreements we had was whether or not a young woman with her lack of role models could turn out to be sort of naïve, not overly self-protective. A couple of us thought of examples of people who came from horrible circumstances and still managed to hold onto a sort of innocence, but it is not perceived to be the norm.
Jill seems to some to be too sarcastic; her goth façade is not appealing to others. Still more of us just see the grief that fuels her anger. Alice lost her father at the age of 13, and she couldn’t relate to Jill’s anger. A few of us with teens in our houses could relate to a child who doesn’t really want to share what’s happening in their life. But Sue pointed out that at the beginning of the story, you think you know who Jill and Mandy are. And over the course of the book, you find out who they really are. That’s a pretty nice compliment to a character-driven novel.

Dylan and Ravi, the two love interests in the book, are possibly the nicest two teen males we’ve ever “met.” Understanding, kind, perceptive. They put up with everything and help the women to find their better selves. This is where the book might be putting a toe or two over the line into fantasy, but we’re down with it.
We also talked briefly about the sexual activity of the two female protagonists. Do we, as adults, feel like this is appropriate for the intended teen girl audience? Zarr herself said in an interview with The Williams Telos that she “never wanted to wind up in a position where I was being asked to soft-pedal the adolescent experience.” A couple of moms in the group agreed that you have to be real with your teens—“you know what we think; this is someone else’s perspective, and we don’t need to be afraid to hear what other people say.”

Julie, our resident expert on Denver, verified that Casa Bonita was the perfect restaurant for Mandy’s party. But the talk of “Margins” bookstore in the book just made us wish we could go to The Tattered Cover. If you know Denver, you know what we mean.
Because I led the meeting this month, and because I am sort of a Sara Zarr fan (verging slightly on groupie), I had to take the opportunity to tell everyone about Once Was Lost, Zarr’s book previous to this one and one of my favorites. It is such a wonderful story. Go read it now, if you enjoy young adult lit. But I digress.

Why is it called How to Save a Life? We could think of many whose lives were saved. But the prevailing way to do so seemed to be to trust. Mandy and Jill had to have enough trust in those who loved them to open up and share what was going on.

We eventually had to quit talking because Helen had brought some apple crisp that was calling to us. Oh so worth it. It might not save a life, but it sure makes it better.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Neland ladies get down and dirty with "The Dirty Life"

In the memoir, The Dirty Life, by Kristin Kimball, a young, single Manhattanite journalist interviews an organic farmer, and they fall in love. Somehow she finds herself moving from her SoHo apartment into heavy labor on a farm that uses horses instead of tractors. That transformation is as amazing to her as it is to the reader.

The Neland women had an evening of memories talking about this book. For one thing, we found out that at least three of the dozen or so women there had grown up on farms, and many more had grown up in farm towns or had relatives with farms. I, on the other hand, have basically zero connection to the soil. I did visit a pig farm once in high school, which was a very educational moment for this city girl. This disconnect may be why my garden beans look so poorly, and it may explain a few of the shudders that came over me as I read the book.
Actually I really liked it, and so did the rest of the group. Kristin and, more to the point, her eventual husband Mark, were very ambitious. They decided to begin a new community organic farm that was sustainable and which would provide everything the members needed—milk, eggs, meat, flour, veggies, fruit, etc.  Many of us use or have tried CSA shares of farms. I just have one question--if you have to spend so much time educating people on what to do with kale because they don't really like it, why grow so much of it? But I digress.

We all got tired just reading about farming—milking cows, weeding row upon row of vegetables, tapping the sugar bush. They would fall into bed at the end of long days of work—ew—without energy for a shower.

Alice remembered milking cows every day and the sort of rhythmic comfort that you could take in the routine. She also wondered how it could possibly take 2 hours to milk one cow. Rebecca and I, who have mothered slow nursers, just nodded knowingly.
Those who know about such things talked about the dirt and the smell of a farm, how hard they are to get rid of. They also talked about how good fresh vegetables and milk taste. Some found it hard to change to store-bought milk; others didn’t seem to notice the difference.

Deanna remembered moving onto a farm in late middle school, and going through the same adjustment from city to farm with mixed feelings and completely new experiences.
All of us had some feeling that Mark would be a difficult man to be married to. He seemed very rigid, like things must be the way he envisions them. No one seemed to think they could live for any period of time with a composting toilet in the middle of a shabby apartment.

But, on the other hand, the man could cook. And Kristin could write about cooking. The combination made me think that even I might try a tasty liver. But never—seriously—a cow heart or, ahem, "prairie oysters." Nuh-uh. And Holly pointed out that there are moments where he capitulates to Kristin’s wishes immediately and with no questions asked. They seem perfect for each other.
We laughed about the idealization of her newfound love at the beginning of the book, where she wished that every woman might have the chance to be with a man who has never smoked, gotten drunk, or slept around. That doesn’t seem like such a lofty goal to the many of us who are married to such men.

But for all the laughter, Kimball writes beautifully. She uses lovely metaphors that bring you right into the farm. And the wedding, which seems such a crazy affair, is something I would love to go to someday. Mark has a vision for farming that takes in the sacredness of creation and the relationship of humans to the earth. The book and Kimball's writing made the dirty life seem like something to dream of and strive for, helping us reconnect with some of our agricultural pasts.


Wednesday, July 25, 2012

The Secret Lives in "Silver Sparrow"

I've gotten very far behind in posting the books I've been reading, so this week I'll be doing some marathan blogging to try to catch up a bit.

The Fab 5 Book Club met, oh, some time ago, to talk about Silver Sparrow by Tayari Jones. But first we ate some great Mexican food, from a restaurant that was closed by the health department shortly thereafter. We’re not sure whether we should be sad or grateful that we escaped with our lives.

We also talked a bit about pet-sitting. One upcoming vacation prompted the need for a rat-sitter. Then Nancy mentioned that she once did some cat-sitting for a friend, a friend who left a sticky note on every conceivable surface with instructions about the cat, the food, the way the toilet flushed, etc. Cat people may respond here in their own defense, but it seems there is something about anyone who owns multiple cats that puts them under the shadow of suspicion.

But about the book. Dana and Chaurisse are sisters, but only one of them knows it. They share a father, James Witherspoon, and Dana has spent her life as the product of his secret marriage. Chaurisse, on the other hand, is the daughter of his public wife and has lived a pampered, sheltered life. The book is written from Dana’s perspective in the first half, and the second half comes from Chaurisse.

All of us were caught by the story, wanting to know what happened. We spent some time wondering what it would be like to find out that your father has a whole different family. And what it would be like to grow up knowing that. Children look to their parents for their identity—to find out how much they are loved, to try to figure out where they fit in the list of parental priorities. Daughters look to their fathers for the male perspective on themselves, and they watch their parents’ interactions to find out what marriage might look like for themselves.

To grow up as part of a secret family, your needs always second to that of the public family, means that you are not first priority. But on the other hand, growing up in a secure family with no knowledge of the other family, makes your life and the love you’ve experienced a fraud. It’s a fascinating puzzle to consider.

Identity is a huge issue for everyone involved—a man who doesn’t want to work for anyone else, his brother who looks white but is not, and two women who may or may not be beloved wives. The book points out how much of our identity is shaped by our relationship to others and how we are perceived.

On top of that, Jones sets the story in 1980s Atlanta, which had us all think back on jelly shoes and Add-a-Bead necklaces. Okay, I’m the only one who knew about Add-a-Beads. Must have been a southern thing. There were some cracks in the 80s description—I can’t think of anyone who was fashionably sporting a tube top in the mid-80s—but still kind of fun.

The biggest downfall for us is that none of us could quite understand how the character of James Witherspoon warranted all this female attention in the first place. While it is still missing something to make it great, it is an interesting, well-written story.


Thursday, May 17, 2012

An Enormous Book of Enormous Consequence

The Neland Women’s Book Club met tonight (yes, they’ve met more often than I have recorded, because I’ve been unable to attend for a couple of months now). We talked about The Warmth of Other Suns by Isabel Wilkerson. This book is about the Great Migration, the massive movement of African Americans from the southern states to the north in the 20th century. I’ll say right now that I did not finish the book, so some of this is inferred information from the group. Ladies, if I have something wrong, please correct me in the comments!

Our leader of the month, Sue, helped us wade through the issues and information presented by the book. She mentioned that Wilkerson is a journalist, the first African American woman to win the Pulitzer Prize for journalism in 1994. She was interested in the subject of the migration because of her own parents’ migration, and she spent 15 years researching and interviewing 1200 people for this project.

Between World War I and the 1970s about 6 million African Americans migrated north. That’s in comparison, for example, to the 300,000 “Okies” who famously left the Oklahoma area for the west coast during the Dust Bowl. Jim Crow laws, lynchings, and an extremely restrictive caste system led the people of the Great Migration to leave all they knew, in mostly rural areas, to have more freedoms and opportunities. Unfortunately, they tended to find it difficult to gain employment, restricted housing options and cities infected with crime.
The recently migrated were willing to work hard to make a life for themselves, but their children found it frustrating to live with a lack of prospects, and they were living in community with African-Americans who had already been living in the north and who were already frustrated.

Wilkerson uses a form called narrative nonfiction to follow three people in particular: Ida Mae Gladney, Robert Foster and George Starling. Sue noted that George was from the same area in Florida where Trayvon Martin lost his life. Wilkerson says she used three books as her models: The Grapes of Wrath, Avalon, and The Joy Luck Club.
I personally was utterly floored to find out that immediately after emancipation, former slaves had many rights, and that those were slowly taken away. I had always been under the impression that Jim Crow laws were pretty much in force from Day 1 after emancipation. And so the former slaves, who had at least a forced and artificial relationship with the white community, had children and grandchildren who had basically zero relationship with the white community. The white community over the years built up a sort of hysteria, basically psychotically afraid of giving black neighbors any power or rights.

Sue said that it is amazing to realize that all of this happened basically in her lifetime, and she was so unaware. Alice said it is one of the saddest books she’s ever read, but she hastened to add that it was excellent. Both of them remembered a time long ago in their Chicago-area neighborhood when the white church community there felt threatened by the arrival of African Americans.
The only criticism that we heard was that the book was somewhat repetitive. That criticism was, fittingly enough, repeated by several people. However, there was some feeling that with all the information presented, some repetition helps the reader retain the important points.

We talked some about how this informs our perspective on our own town of Grand Rapids. Certainly people migrated to GR, and GR suffered white flight. We questioned the role of Christian schools in making our city more segregated, since in the early days the Christian schools served a white community. We wonder how much racism prevails even now, when we don’t even realize it.
A line from the book about Robert Joseph Pershing Foster, who was a educated as a medical doctor and ran into obstacles everywhere he went because of his skin color: “Still it made no sense to Pershing that one set of people could be in a cage, and the people outside couldn’t see the bars.” What bars are right in front of us that we never notice? And how does that affect us in ways that we don’t realize?

In a speech, Wilkerson said this: “I believe that the next migration has to be for us as individuals, as human beings, to recognize that we have so much more in common than we are led to believe. And to recognize that when everyone does better, everyone does better."


Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Fab 5 Book Club: The Glass Castle

Tonight the Fab 5 had yet another intense, esoteric book discussion. I actually had to look up esoteric just now to make sure it meant what I wanted to say, which, once you read the definition is rather ironic. I’ll let you get your own dictionary if you need to.

Anyway. The Fab 5 tackled The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls. This memoir recounts Walls’s childhood as part of a family that was one part comedy, one part lunacy and one part tragedy. Walls and her three siblings lived a nomadic life with their parents. Mom was an artist, a trained teacher, and always looking for the new bright horizon just waiting to be discovered. Dad was an alcoholic charmer, a highly intelligent man who was more comfortable hustling pool than working steadily at an actual job. He had big dreams, or delusions, depending on your perspective.

The children learned to read early and well, they learned about living frugally and simply, and they moved frequently in search of the next adventure. They lived all over the desert southwest, a vast playground and habitat study for the children, and they eventually moved to the town in West Virginia where their father grew up.  Dad was always on the verge of a new, spectacular invention. One of his plans was to built the Glass Castle, a scientifically designed house made of glass and tailored especially for their family.

 The kids were also often neglected severely, especially as alcohol claimed more and more prominence in their father’s life. Early on there were periods of time where food ran short, memorably a time when young Jeannette was hungry enough to eat the only thing left in the fridge—a stick of margarine. One move saw the children locked into the back of a U-Haul truck for what might be a 14 hour drive, with no way to communicate with their parents. As they got older, they went through periods of time where everyone in the family fended for themselves for food—scavenging the remains of classmates discarded lunch bags, finding ways to get invited to dinner at other people’s houses.
We wondered how these young people remained hopeful, kept their goals in sight, and seemed to feel loved, for the most part. This is an interesting point, after a Bible study discussion I took part in today. We talked about Job, and how he felt right before God, even though everything pointed to God's dismissal of him. We each thought a bit about how and when we have felt "approved of"--and how so often it feels to a child that their parents don't really approve. In this book, the children seem to feel their parents' approval as far as that goes, which serves them well as they push at the boundaries of their isolated lives.

Walls is a great writer, and she manages to tell incredibly sad stories with beauty and wit. That almost goes without saying, since this dark family tale turned out to be one of our favorite reads in a long time. Somehow she makes readers a tiny bit jealous at certain points that we didn’t grow up with such footloose and adventurous parents, even when it was obviously not something to be envied!

Eventually, though, we proved our incapacity for such an unplanned and uncertain lifestyle. Host Nancy produced two miniature boxes of chocolates—one Whitman sampler, and one Russell Stover. Neither box had a little chart telling us the filling of each candy. Rather than throwing caution to the wind and each claiming two unknown pieces of chocolate, Nancy carefully cut each chocolate in half so we could see what kind we were getting. No one got an unexpected coconut or maple filling, and everyone was happy. I kind of don’t think we would make it with the Walls family.

Jeannette Walls has also written a book called Half Broke Horses, about her tough-as-nails grandmother. Nancy and Sonya have both read it and recommend it. I’m hoping to read it soon!

Friday, February 24, 2012

Wendell Berry's "Jayber Crow"

Last night the Fab 5 met to choose our books for the next six months, a meeting that is always filled with anticipation. And very difficult decision-making. Four people brought 36 books. Yikes. We pored over them, and in the end were rewarded with a list of 6 books we are very excited to read.

But now I go back to our last meeting, when we discussed Jayber Crow by Wendell Berry. The reason I did not write about it at the time is that I had not finished it yet. So we had two discussions about it, last month and this month.

Jayber Crow is about an “ineligible bachelor barber” making his way through life. Orphaned at an early age, Jayber (born Jonah, hint hint) first considers ministry, then finds his way back to his birthplace to settle in and live his life alone, but not always lonely.

I’m probably one of the last to come to the Wendell Berry party. And I am knocked out by his characterization, his description, and his compassion for every character in the book. It took some patience and some deliberateness to make my way through it, but I was rewarded.

This book is about Jayber, first and foremost, a man you come to love. It is also about small towns, generational differences, the change in farming from small homesteads to big agriculture, and the beauty of nature that we both treasure and destroy.

It is also a novel layered with religious imagery, from floods to rainbows, from death to resurrection, from rebirth to sacrificial love, from hell to heaven. And you can’t help but draw the parallel between Jayber Crow and Jesus Christ.

[Spoiler alert]

Jayber, though by no means a perfect man, lives a solitary life, surrounded mostly by men, and is “reborn” to a cold, lonely earth when he flees his old life by pushing himself through a tiny bathroom window at a dance hall. He makes a personal commitment to a woman who has given herself to someone else, and vows to treasure her and love her in the way that he can, from a distance. In their later years, he walks with her, just enjoying her company, through a beautiful wooded area.

The final scene brings the two together as the wooded area is being logged. It brought to mind one of my favorite Over the Rhine songs, “The Trumpet Child.” “The trumpet child will lift a glass / his bride now leaning in at last / his final aim to fill with joy / the earth that man all but destroyed.” That image of joyful union amidst the ruins of sin has always given me goosebumps, and I loved seeing a new iteration of it in Jayber Crow.

Now, having said all that I just did, I should point out that Berry starts off the novel with a warning against finding subtexts, explanations and interpretations, stating that people who do what I have just done should be “exiled to a desert island in the company only of other explainers.” Would that really be so bad???

Wednesday, January 18, 2012

"Dandelion Wine": What books remind you of summer?

In the dead of winter, what’s better than a taste of summer? You could have ice cold lemonade, but there’s that whole “cold” thing. Or you can put on your bathing suit, but that also has numerous drawbacks. Instead, how about a book that brings summer back to you?

Ray Bradbury’s Dandelion Wine bottles up the summer of 1928 for all time.

The Fab 5 met to talk about it during a December snow drought. Our hostess lives a ways out, so we were glad about that. We told her we’d only drive to her house in the wintertime if she promised to decorate their mounted bear for Christmas. She obliged.

Dandelion Wine seems to be a novel that draws deeply on the author’s childhood in small-town Illinois. Most of Bradbury’s work is science fiction,, and we were surprised to find that this novel is often categorized as science fiction as well. I wouldn’t call it sci-fi, but sometimes it borders on magical realism.

Douglas Spaulding is twelve years old and has the entire summer spread out before him. He determines to pay attention, to notice things. His eyes are beginning to open to life, mortality, and the temporal nature of things. Through Bradbury’s descriptions, you can smell, feel, taste summer.

You’ll also be reminded of how different a young boy’s life is now. Douglas and Tom are watching things change before their eyes. The town’s trolley is being swapped out for buses. People are growing up, growing old, and dying. And the boys are observing their neighbors intently, finding surprises for the better and worse.

We were reminded of Olive Kitteridge in that this novel is actually a collection of stories all related by time, setting and recurring characters.

Sonya’s favorite story was about an elderly woman, Helen, and a young man named Bill who develop a close connection. They come to wonder if they are soulmates who have been meeting each other at the wrong time in their lives and that someday maybe they’ll be reborn as agemates as well, so that they can be together. It’s very sweet. Sort of reminds me of the Ben Folds song “The Luckiest.”

We were not sucked into the story right away. It took a while to catch our interest, several of us citing the story about 1/5 of the way in about another elderly woman who is visited by some little girls who refuse to believe she’d ever been young. It’s kind of sad; the woman decides that they are right—she is not the same person anymore, and there is no point to holding onto all of the mementos she has saved up, because they cannot make her that person. This was particularly hard for one of us to take, since she has a natural tendency to save up some mementos of her own!

The book grew on me as I read it, and I am happy I did. What books remind you of summer?

Thursday, December 15, 2011

The Neland Women's Book Club Takes on "Okay for Now"

Neland represented today with a big group, as was to be expected since we were discussing our own Gary Schmidt’s young adult novel, Okay for Now. While I blogged about my reading of this book back in March, hearing the insights of other people always gives me a new appreciation. I scattered chairs around the living room, and people were kind enough to peer at each other around the Christmas tree without mentioning the obvious obstacle it presented!


Our leader tonight was Lisa, who had never even been to book club before, but somehow she ended up leading. Boy are we glad she did!

We were full of praise for this book, not just because every last one of us a secret fan crush on Gary, but because it’s really good. Really good. He ties together the broken state of our lives and the wholeness that we hope for, throwing in love, mercy and forgiveness, plus a good sense of humor, for good measure. What more could you want?

The abusive father was so terrible. We want the mother to step up and do something, stand up and protect. Why did she stay and allow her children to be subjected to this? Also, how could a principal be so awful? We had questions. In the end, though, those are the same questions that we wonder every day when we watch the news. How could a wife stand by a man who has been abusing children? How could a teacher have an affair with a student? How could children bully each other online to the point of one committing suicide? It goes on. That’s the broken nature of the world.

And Doug Swieteck’s world is broken. His father is abusive, his brother is in Vietnam, his other brother is getting into trouble, and Doug himself is newly stranded in a new town that he hates, a hatred augmented by his attitude and a learning deficiency. Vietnam plays such a crucial part of both the times (late 1960s) and the story. It’s a symbol of the broken nation that we live in, of broken humanity, and broken bodies. Things are not going well.

Okay for Now brings a bit of wholeness back to the world, just as Doug is attempting to make whole both his life and an Audubon book that is being taken apart. Using Jane Eyre and the art of John James Audubon to broaden Doug’s life, Schmidt illustrates the need we all have for a hope and a future. He discusses art and composition knowledgably and brings in a multitude of various characters in the small town who help Doug take steps toward wholeness.

One memorable moment in the book is when Doug’s brother is finally called by name. His name is Christopher, and our friend Karen brought up the fact that St. Christopher is remembered for his strength in carrying people across a raging river. You’ll have to read the book to see how this fits with the Christopher in the novel.

We always spend a portion of our time talking about the things we didn’t like about the book. We couldn’t skip that just because we know the author, right? So we tried to get critical. Yes, a lot of things happen very quickly to this young man. And yes, there are a few coincidences that, if we think too hard about them, seem contrived. But the overall effect is that of redemption and forgiveness, beauty and hope, in the face of great difficulty.

And Lisa read from the review that Richard Peck (yes, that Richard Peck) published in the New York Times. In the midst of a gushing review, he said this: “’Okay for Now’ is crowded with more incident and empowerment than any eighth-grade year or novel can quite contain. Events stretch credulity. At one point, Doug turns up briefly on the Broadway stage, playing a female role, no less. But Schmidt is a master of the unlikely.” If Richard Peck can overlook a few things, who are we to say otherwise?! Not to mention the book was a finalist for the National Book Award, and looks to be a favorite for the Newbery.

How dark should a novel for middle school and early high school students be? This novel has some very dark moments, but we also felt like some of the things that might “stretch credulity” make it more accessible and more appropriate for the target audience. And the end result a novel full of hope and restoration, even though things are not all neatly wrapped up. I just finished reading this book aloud to my 12-year-old, and I felt like the novel went about as far to the dark side as she could handle, and yet it left her happy and hopeful. It also mirrored the emotional ups and downs of this period of her life.

Okay for Now is simply a wonderful book, and we wholeheartedly recommend it.

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Book Club Classic: Anna Karenina

Last summer, the Neland Women's Book Club sat in a circle and caressed books lovingly, holding them up so we could all see the covers and doing our best to sell everyone else on the books we wanted to read. With 12 slots to fill, one a month, it's hard to make the choices. Roze wanted to read Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina. She sold us on it, in spite of the fear and trembling that the combination of the words "Russian novel" and "870 pages" inspired.

Tonight she took the reins as leader, and what a fine job she did. It's a gamble to choose a long, older book, as there is always the fear that maybe only three people will show up. Tonight we had a baker's dozen, and we had a wonderful discussion. We also got prizes. Roze quizzed us with a gift bag full of items--we were supposed to identify what each item had to do with the novel. The tiny bottle of vodka was the most remarked-upon item. And she had a gift bag for all of us, so look out, world.

This in spite of the fact that many of us could not answer the questions. A couple of us had not had time to read the book but only watched the movie or scanned the Cliff's Notes. Which is exactly where I would have been myself if I hadn't read it in an unexplained fit of classics reading 8 years ago. And frankly, I remembered very little. So this discussion both reminded me of what I read back then and opened up the story in new ways.

The book is made up of contrasts. City vs. country. Nobility vs. peasant. Social codes vs. true morality. Male vs. female. Is it any wonder that he wrote a book called War and Peace? And the characters come through clearly because they contrast against each other.

We spent a bit of time wondering why this novel is entitled Anna Karenina, when Levin seems to be the more important character. A couple of theories came up: perhaps the fact that the book was published serially in a magazine over the course of a couple of years meant that the story started out with Anna, but later Levin came to be more important. Or perhaps Anna is the symbol of the old order--nobility that is going down, while the peasants and the hardworking landowners are on the rise.

Many expressed their frustration with Anna and the other characters, tired of reading through their every self-absorbed thoughts. And how could Anna have left her beloved son for this new lover? One of our new friends, Ying He, had a more compassionate point of view of Anna, saying that Anna's tragedy was meeting Vronsky. If she hadn't, she might have found happiness in spending time with her son and in the benefits of her social world, even though her older husband was not ideal. When she met Vronsky, it was like feeling the warmth of a nearby fire, and she wanted more of the heat. In the end she destroyed herself getting to close to the fire. This is, after all, the very nature of temptation--being drawn in by something that enlivens, quickens and warms you, only to find that if you pursue it, you pursue self-destruction. She also mentioned that the choices in real life are not clear-cut; you don't just choose A or B, because there are complex consequences to either choice. In this novel, Tolstoy recognizes and reflects the complexity of those life choices.

Helen mentioned [spoiler alert] that she knew going in that Anna was going to throw herself in front of a train, and at a certain point she was so tired of Anna that she couldn't wait for it to happen. Then she read somewhere that the thought processes as Anna contemplates her demise are some of the most beautifully written in literature. Huh.

We, on the other hand, found some beautiful writing at the moment of Levin's conversion. "He had lived (without being aware of it) on those spiritual truths that he had sucked in with his mother's milk, but he had thought, not merely without recognition of these truths, but studiously ignoring them. Now it was clear to him that he could only live by virtue of the beliefs in which he had been brought up." Hope for the parent of children who are wandering. Then later, "'Can this be faith?' he thought, afraid to believe in his happiness. 'My God, I thank Thee!' he said, gulping down his sobs, and with both hands brushing away the tears that filled his eyes." Here is where I must admit that I remember nothing of this lovely scene from my long-ago reading. I think at that point I had been working so hard to finish the book that I was reading without comprehending!

Russia was moving into a new paradigm--the serfs had been freed, and the old order was threatened. Tolstoy had made some contributions to social reform for the peasants, and this novel has a romanticized view of peasant life. Levin lives on his land, works in the field with the peasants and enjoys their festivities. The problems of the poor little rich girls seem much more complex than the lives of the people living on the land, perhaps because Tolstoy knew more of those problems. Certainly the people working the land had their own challenges, but we are not so privy to them.

Thelma's husband listened to the entire book on CD with her on a road trip. He said that Anna just needed a job. She, herself, thinks that Tolstoy needed an editor; this story could have been told with much less detail. Meanwhile, Marti suggests that if we met Anna now, we'd just recommend a good therapist to deal with her fragility and anxieties.

Sue recommends highly the PBS Masterpiece Theater version of the book. I'm looking forward to it.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

What's in a Desk?

In the spirit of fall clean-up, the Fab 5 took on a big project: the book Great House by Nicole Krauss. This is no small effort--it takes up a big piece of real estate on the bookshelf, and it is not a quick and easy read. Add to that another hurdle. This is one depressing book. We met at Barbara's house, and she was afraid that if she finished it over the weekend, we would be walking in to find her still in her bathrobe with greasy hair, given up on life thanks to the novel.

So far I'm not really selling this book, and book club doesn't sound like so much fun.

We kicked off the evening with a travelogue by yours truly, where I showed them several hundred photos of my family eating pasta and gelato. If you want to know more about our month away, you too can get my travelog (don't worry, no several hundred photos there) on the blog we kept for our families: quistworldtour.blogspot.com.

But I digress. The travelogue helped us procrastinate beginning our discussion, which I sensed several of us were sort of dreading. In the end, though, this book offered a lot to talk about, even if none of us really liked it. It's a strange thing to know that you can appreciate a book that you don't like. But there it is.

The book is very cerebral. While the characters are fully developed, everything that happens in the book, for the most part, seems to happen in their heads, and it takes some hard work to wrap your hands and mind around something concrete. Every character has constructed an idea of themselves and their lives, and they bend their lives around that construction.

One man has an idea of who his wife is and what there relationship is, and every move he makes is shaped by what he thinks she wants and needs. A woman spends a good portion of her life writing at an odd, imposing desk, building a career for which she gives up everything else. When she feels she must give the desk to someone else, she feels that her writing is over. A father's life and marriage are rearranged to try to fit around the constructions of who he thinks his children are. A pair of siblings live their lives around their concept of their father, a man whose own life is built around the memory of his father. Everyone has experienced loss, and everyone is trying to figure out how what they remember fits with who they are and who those important people in their lives really were.

The desk that the writer gives up shows up in different times and places in most of the stories. It is an enormous, imposing desk with lots of oddly-shaped drawers, and it has one drawer that is locked. As far as we can tell, the desk has had a strange, foreboding sort of effect on everyone who has come across it, and they have all wondered about the locked drawer. At the end of the story (spoiler alert!), we find out that the drawer was empty when it was locked. Many have wondered about it, speculated about the secret and possibly valuable contents, but no one has tried to open it. And there is nothing inside.

This emptiness echoes through the lives of the characters--all believe there is a very important secret that they could discover if they tried, but for the most part they don't even try. And if they do, they find more emptiness.

Your can see how this is not such an uplifting book. The thing of it is, as I read, I could see that this is the work of a master writer. It is beautifully written, lovely language. But so painfully sad. I have read The History of Love by the same author, and though this book seems to get the most lavish praise, I would recommend that one instead of Great House.

We ended up our evening with some karaoke-style singing from Nancy, minus the karaoke machine. She graced us with some enthusiastic renditions of ELO songs, which will forever change my perception of that particular band....She has some Strange Magic.

I did skip writing about the last book we read, Property by Valerie Martin. This was a novel about a rather enigmatic main character, the wife of a plantation owner. She was trapped in her marriage, but the slaves that served the couple were trapped in even more severe ways. Again, this is not the most uplifting book, and the characters were not very likeable. Sonya had recently read Someone Knows My Name by Lawrence Hill, which also dealt with slavery. She highly recommends it over Property. If you want to read something by Valerie Martin, I recommend Mary Reilly, her take on Dr. Jeckyll and Mr. Hyde. It's sort of a creepy, romantic, gothic novel that is much better than the little-known Julia Roberts movie made from it.

Next up for the Fab 5: Dandelion Wine by Ray Bradbury. Soaking up a little summer sun in the early winter!

Thursday, September 8, 2011

Back from a Long Break!

Well, it seems I took the summer off from my blog. I didn't mean to, it just somehow happened. So I'll give you a quick update on what I've been reading this summer. I'd love to hear what you've been reading too!

At the very beginning of the summer, the Fab 5 Book Club met to talk about Olive Kitteridge by Elisabeth Strout. That book is full of sadness and horrible events, stars a crabby, rather unlikeable protagonist, and is so wonderfully developed that you can't help but keep reading and even liking it! Olive is a main character like no other, her life told in bits and pieces by a string of characters from her hometown in Maine, and Strout is such a great writer that you can empathize with this person you would not necessarily want to know in real life.

We also took in I Am Number Four, a young adult sci-fi/fantasy novel about aliens come to earth by a conglomeration of writers under the pseudonym Pittacus Lore. It's a fast-paced, fun read that grabs you from the beginning and also falls prey to a number of moments that seem engineered to grab the attention of a teen reader. Good looking alien male lead? Check. Gorgeous, perfect girlfriend? Check. A book-long chase sequence? Check. New kid not fitting in with a school bully? You guessed it, Check. The language was needlessly rough. Yet there is something catchy, charming about it. The movie didn't live up to the book. Now the sequel is out, and I've heard it's better than the first. And the original was good enough that 2 of the 4 of us had trouble sleeping because they were kind of freaked out.

The Neland Ave Church Women's Book Club contemplated Coop by Michael Perry. I love Michael Perry, which you may know from earlier posts. I read his book Population: 485 a year or two ago, and then I heard him speak (twice) at Calvin College at the last Festival of Faith and Writing. A down home intellectual, he effortlessly moves from farm life to mechanics to fatherhood to the writing life to philosophy to art to small-town Wisconsin to cooking and on and on. Lovely. So, back to the Neland Book Club and Coop. In Coop, the recently-married 40ish Perry is newly living on his mother-in-law's former farm, attempting with his wife to begin a more self-sustaining life. Raising chickens, in particular, is a major goal. They garden and get pigs and get chickens and rear 2 daughters. In the meantime he also considers the way that he was raised--his parents' endless love, religious beliefs and faithful patience for a string of foster children and adoptive children. It's lovely and gritty and real and touching.

And then just recently the Fab 5 got together to discuss Truck: A Love Story, also by Michael Perry. (If you are sensing a common thread here, namely me, you may just be on to something). Truck backs up a bit to the year that Perry meets the wife he so tenderly describes in Coop. He is intent on restoring the 50s-era International pickup truck he's had for 20 years, which can only actually happen due to the talent of his brother-in-law Mark. Again, Perry is hilarious and earthy and gentle. Did I mention how much I love his work?

Enough. Also on the summer's checklist was the book Soul Searching, by Christian Smith and Melina Lundquist Denton. I was really under the gun with this one. I volunteered to lead the discussion for the Neland women, and with a 3 week camping trip I thought I'd have plenty of time to dig into it. The camping trip was great, but about a week in we had the misfortune of noticing that our youngest child was scratching her head in earnest at the Grand Canyon. Turned out she had head lice. I spent the rest of my free should-have-been-reading time picking through her hair, which satisfied neither of us but rectified the situation. And so I had to speed-read the book when I got home, something I am not very good at doing.

Actually, this is a really interesting book, a sociological study of the spiritual lives of teens in the early 2000s. I have to admit that due to time restraints I had to skip the chapter directed specifically to parents and youth workers in the Catholic Church. But the overall gist of the book is that young people are interested in spiritual things, are willing to go along with what their parents believe, and for the most part have adopted a "Moralistic Therapeutic Deism". In other words, their religion serves them as a tool to make them feel better, happier, rather than asking them to serve a God who loves them sacrificially and asks the same of them. This has major implications for churches that want to train up a child in the way that he/she should go. If you don't want to take the time to read the whole book, you could get a good bit of it from the Conclusion section. I'm not much of a sociologist, but I'm interested to read through the follow-up book now.

As we toured the Southwest United States, my husband showed me up--he actually finished a book, and it was even relevant to the places we were visiting. He read How the West Was Won by Louis L'amour. His review: "It was okay, but nothing special." Son Andrew read a book called Colorado Ghost Stories, which he truly loved.

I'm about 2/3rds of the way through a sort of modern Gothic novel called The Distant Hours by Kate Morton. It's about a woman who is trying to figure out the connection between her mother and the family who lives in an old estate, the same family and estate her mother joined as a child during World War II when the children of London were evacuated to the country. I keep picking it up, then having to put it down to read something else. Someday I may even finish it. I like it.

A very different read this summer was the book On Becoming a Novelist by John Gardner. I read this in preparation for a fiction workshop that I attended in June. If I had read this book before signing up for the fiction class, I probably would've ended my fiction career right then. Gardner's book is full of good information on the reason for writing, characterization and other practical things, but his description of who the novelist is left me shaking in my boots, sure that there's no chance I could fit into that category! Then I spent a wonderful week having the novelist Bret Lott lead my class through our manuscripts and about 5 million useful tips for writing. We'll see if I ever have the guts to return to my manuscript.

So it's been a great summer, and now back to real life. Maybe I'll be more faithful to my blog again. We'll see.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

Take This Bread: Feeding the Good Shepherd's Sheep

Where to start with this book? The Neland ladies met to talk about Take This Bread two months ago, I finished it a month ago, and it's taken me this long to write about it. That's not due to a lack of interest on my part. There is so much in this book that I had to chew on, one piece at a time (no pun intended).

Sara Miles is a left-wing, lesbian journalist who was raised in an intentionally secular home by parents who both grew up as mission kids. Sara is also a Christian, quite possibly a follower of Christ like none you have met before.

Food had always been an important part of her life, including experiences like sharing food with poor revolutionaries in Central America in the 70s and working in a restaurant.

One day, on a whim, Sara entered St. Gregory's Episcopal Church in San Francisco. She sat through the church service, observing, until it came time for communion. St. Gregory's has open communion, and Sara took it. The experience was completely unexpected, and it changed her life.

Sara became a member of St. Gregory's, and soon she organized a food pantry at the church. The pantry began to attract 200 people or more on any given Friday. Her experience led her into a lot of "church" issues, namely that being part of a church congregation means being in communion with people you don't necessarily like, trust, or even want to be associated with. God lives inside of people we don't even like! Sara has a particular love for the different, the broken, the needy; she sees that truly, that's who we all are at the foot of the cross.

Annetta, our leader for the night, shared with us that she has been to St. Gregory's for worship. She reports that it is a lovely place with beautiful music, a wonderful experience. This book club meeting was very well attended, and most people loved the book even if they didn't agree with everything in it.

This meeting reminded me of a discussion we had a few years back after reading Anne Lamott's book Traveling Mercies. We all loved hearing Anne speak at Calvin and reading her book. She's so funny, alive, self-deprecating, and joyous. Then we wondered what would happen if she walked into Neland. She wouldn't be "like us." Same goes for Sara Miles, in some ways. Would we be welcoming? We'd like to think so.

Personally, I have been recognizing several things about my spiritual life and worship experience which this book illuminates. I am craving diversity of community in my church body--diversity of skin color, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, educational status, any and all of it. I am inspired by people who are seeing Christianity as a holistic identity--I don't just think like a Christian, I am Christian in body and soul. Which means that a more physical, incarnational experience is important to me. And so Sara's description of the patchwork nature of the food pantry, as well as the pantry's ability to feed people in both body and soul, really hit home for me. I'm still fumbling my way through trying to figure out what this all means to my day-to-day life.


If you think you might have a dim view of a Sara Miles when she walks into your church, be assured that she may take a dim view of your church as well. Several passages about the kinds of attitudes or arguments or bottlenecks or inertia that hamper ministry hit painfully close to home. If you have been in a traditional church for any length of time, something in this book is likely to offend or hit you wrong. But the basic principle, that Jesus asks us to "feed his sheep," is irrefutable. And Sara, while disdaining doctrine, has a good handle on both Scripture and the life of Christ.

She points out that we should specialize in the "undeserving poor," since that's exactly what we all are. So while you might feel you should take it with a grain of salt, you should definitely Take This Bread.

Thursday, June 2, 2011

A Different Look at the Holocaust: Sarah's Key

Julia Jarmond is an American journalist, living in Paris and married to a Frenchman. She is assigned to write about the 60th commemoration of the Vel d'Hiv. Never heard of it? Neither had the Fab 5. Nor many others, according to Sarah's Key, a novel by Tatiana de Rosnay..

On July 16, 1942, French police, on orders from the Gestapo, rounded up 10,000 Jewish people, including children, from the Paris area. They were brought to the Velodrome d'Hiver, an indoor stadium, where they were held for six days while more and more people were packed in. Terrible heat, little food and no facilities made it unbearable. From there they were shipped out to camps, eventually ending at Auschwitz.

Julia learns about this atrocity, but at the same time she learns the story of one of those individuals--Sarah, a young girl who suffered an extra tragedy when she was taken from her home during the roundup. Julia is dealing with personal problems of her own, and Sarah's story makes her look at everything in her life in a new light.

This book does a great job of introducing us to the event itself, to the people who suffered through it, and to both the profound effect on survivors as well as the wish to ignore or forget the event on the part of those who watched it happen.

None of us could stand Julia's husband. If an American had written this, we'd assume she doesn't really like French people, but she is, in fact, French. Having Julia be an American, always on the outside regardless of how long she'd been in France, was a nice parallel to how Jewish people may have experienced the cultures they lived in during World War II.

Some of us found it frustrating that the novel flips back and forth from Sarah's story to Julia's modern-day life. Just when we'd get into one, we'd switch back to the other. However, we wonder if we could stand to read Sarah's story straight through--it's just so sad. Julia's story gave us a way to enter the story, some distraction, and a taste of the way France looked at the event 60 years later. And Julia faces some questions about the value of life in her own world as well as in history.

Whenever we read these stories, we can't help but wonder what we'd do if faced with the decision to put ourselves at risk for someone else. Would we endanger our children to hide someone? We'd like to think we are brave enough, but it's hard to be sure.

Are things like this happening now? There are, to some extent, similarities in what America did with Japanese internment camps and Native American reservations--people of a certain ethnicity taken from their homes and put into prescribed areas with little or no resources. It's possible to look at detention centers for illegal immigrants in the same way--basically, they are imprisoned indefinitely and, according to some reports, treated poorly. It happens where we can't see it, has nothing to do with us, and is therefore not our problem.

Sarah's Key is a good, sad novel that manages to keep the reader while telling an "old" tale and giving a fresh perspective on it. Never forget.

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Getting Graphic with the Church Ladies

Okay, we're not like that Church Lady. But the Neland Book Club is a groups of ladies from my church. And this week we took the giant leap into reading a graphic novel together. This month's title was Blankets by Craig Thompson, a book which is easy to mistake for memoir, but is officially "an illustrated novel." Some were a bit unsure about reading it, and one stalwart decided she wouldn't, feeling that the whole point of reading a book is to imagine it. But more about that later.

Jenny Williams, who teaches a college class on the graphic novel, lent us her expertise tonight. Blankets is one of the books she always teaches in that class. Blankets is about a young man who has grown up in a fundamentalist Christian home, isolated and lonely in a culture that discourages his natural artistic talent. He falls in love with a kindred spirit at a Christian winter camp during high school, and he goes to visit her. Their relationship opens a new lens on his life and his talent.

While the character in the novel, named Craig Thompson like the author and with many similarities to the author, does not embrace the church, this book would give any Christian pause, begging the question of what they or their church is communicating to the young people within. This young man experiences sexual abuse at the hands of a babysitter, harsh discipline from his parents, and bullying from his classmates. His faith offered him a future security, but nothing to help him in his current earthly life.

Jenny's students always have a strong response to this book. Many identify with the small-town experience or the feeling of isolation at the Christian camp. They express their disappointment at the end result of the character's experience and mourn the fact that he was not in a good church situation. She said that students are always disappointed to find out that this is not absolutely true to his life story--that there are fictional aspects to the novel.

Interestingly, since this book is highly autobiographical, Jenny also let us know that Thompson did not tell his family that he was writing this book and, in fact, let them know by sending them a copy when it was published.

We discussed the title: what blankets are in the book? There is a blanket that Raina, his newfound girlfriend, makes for him, which is the obvious choice. Then there are the blankets that he and his brother fight over and play amidst when they share a bed as children. There are blankets of snow throughout the book. Blank spaces abound. And given the different uses of a blanket--warming, covering, hiding, suffocating--there are many dimensions to the image. Christianity is a sort of blanket as well--his parents use it as security and comfort; Craig finds it to be something that hides what's really there and suffocates him. Interestingly, in real life, he still has the quilt that his girlfriend made him.

An interesting aspect of the book, which helps explain why he feels so isolated from his parents' faith, is the complete divorce that he feels between Christian spirituality and the physical world. The physical world is dismissed as unworthy of celebration and attention. Why did God create our bodies, nature, a physical earth if it is meaningless? It's an easy trap for Christians to fall into.

I would not give Blankets to just anyone--I think given the questioning of faith and the sexual abuse in the novel, I wouldn't give it to anyone under 16. And sexuality, as part of the physical world that has been cut off from his life, plays a prominent role. Jenny and her students have discussed what the difference is between reading a story and seeing the images of them in a graphic novel. For some, images last longer in their minds, while others have very vivid images from reading text. This goes to discernment for what is important for each individual reader.



Which leads me back to our wonderful friend who is not interested in graphic novels. She doesn't want everything imagined for her. However, the art in a graphic novel is part of the storytelling. The minimal text is informed by the art in a completely different way than illustrations function in traditional texts.

Blankets is a poignant look at one person's experience. It is filled with both sadness and beauty. Craig Thompson will be at the Festival of Faith and Writing at Calvin next April. I'm looking forward to hearing what he has to say, and I pray that the experience of Festival will be a blessing to him. I'm also looking forward to reading more graphic novels. The art gives an added value to the experience, giving some variety to the always-enjoyable time spent reading.

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Off the Reservation

Three weeks ago the Fab 5 Book Club took a road trip, leaving our little Dutch lives to enjoy the different vibe of Cincinnati. It's taken me at least this long to recover enough to write about it! Pretty much we ate our way through the town--three of the original Fab 5 lived in Cincinnati for quite a few years together before we came together. They had lots of favorite places to revisit--Graeter's for ice cream, Skyline Chili, the Grand Finale and more. Sonya claimed she was in a food coma for days. But oh how sweet it was.

We looked out over the city from Carew Tower. We toured neighborhoods like Over the Rhine while listening to, well, Over the Rhine. We all coveted mightily at a most awesome architectural antiques store. We stopped in to see Union Station, where in the bathroom we overheard a young boy, after commenting on the state of his mother's rear end, wondered loudly to his mother why a particular portion of his private anatomy is always sticky, a question answered immediately with a burst of laughter from everyone in the bathroom. So it was a pretty full weekend of entertainment.

We combined this inaugural road trip with our book club discussion of Reservation Blues by Sherman Alexie. In this novel, Thomas Builds-A-Fire and two of his fellow Spokane form a band. At first they perform covers of famous songs, but eventually Thomas writes his own for the band. The success that they achieve is not welcomed by the rest of their tribe. Along the way two white women join their band briefly, and later two women from another tribe join. Each bring their own complications.

We spent some time regretting the fact that we really know very little about Native American culture. The magical realism in the book can sometimes be hard for us to wrap our minds around, and we want to know how much is the author's style and how much of it is cultural. The novelist gives prominence to the importance of dreams and what they tell the dreamer. Sometimes it was hard to separate the dream from the reality in the story, which seems quite intentional, since they are meant to be so closely related.

The sadness of life on the reservation--commodity foods, hunger, poverty, mass alcoholism, unemployment and violence--come to a crescendo at the end of the book. It's not happy. And the even harder-to-understand part of it is the reluctance of the fellow Spokane to rejoice when someone from their reservation has a chance to excel. Because excelling seems to be equivalent to rejecting their history and their people.

These themes came up in young adult novel The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, also by Sherman Alexie. The novels are very similar, but I think that Diary is the more entertaining, better crafted of the two.

One thing I really like about Reservation Blues is that the author used the music to further his theme. In the beginning, when they form their band, they only performed covers of music that was written by other people from other cultures in other struggles. What people expected from them was their "Indian" music, a performance taken out of context, sort of like going to an "authentic luau" at the Quality Inn on Maui.

When Thomas begins to write his own songs, he is creating his own music, influenced by his culture and other music cultures, but bringing them into the modern state of his own experience. I think the author sees that as the same situation that the reservation faces. They can perform to the caricature of their history that is expected by the outside world, they can abandon their own history to adopt someone else's culture, or they can take the best of both worlds to create something meaningful for themselves.

One odd association I had while reading this was the character of Big Mom. She is a puzzling character, possibly deity, possibly human, certainly powerful in a limited way. I read one blog that said she symbolized Time, which is an interesting way to interpret it. At the risk of alienating both friends and foes of the loved and hated book The Shack, Big Mom sort of reminded me of "Papa," the black woman who represented God the Father. Big, caring, irreverent, nurturing. I find it interesting that two such radically different books would come up with a character who has so much in common.

One place where you could find both of those books and so many more is Half Price Books. We do not have one of these lovely institutions here in Grand Rapids, though the Fab 5 are considering opening a store ourselves. We made the pilgrimage to two different Half Price Books while in Cincinnati, much to my dear husband's chagrin. Heavenly places. And I even scored a paperback copy of Alexie's book of short stories The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, which includes many of the characters from Reservation Blues and was the basis for the movie Smoke Signals. I hope to see it soon.

Well, this Big Mom needs to get moving. I know that I do not personify Time, or good use of it, and I have a mountain of chores to attend to. But first, lunch with my mom and sister.

Sunday, March 27, 2011

"Too Much Happiness"--Well, Not So Much

About a week and a half ago, the Neland women tackled Too Much Happiness by Alice Munro. It's taken me until now to actually finish the book and then re-read some of it to figure out what I really thought!

Alice Munro is a Canadian short story writer of formidable skill. She is amazing. But this book is not full of "too much happiness." Most of the short stories are built around sad or disturbing events and people. As one member of our group said, "I don't like any of these characters!"

So, the idea of the book being "good" or "not good" became a bit more complex.

One of Munro's strengths that we agreed on was her ability to draw you into the story. No matter how weird or sad the story will become, she first has you identifying completely with the character. You can recognize things about yourself. So that by the time the weirdness sets in, you can only wonder how you would react in such circumstances. As our leader, also named Alice, put it, Munro has a pretty clear picture of total depravity. And she has a pretty good understanding of how we deceive ourselves into believing that what we choose to do only makes sense, is really the only choice we had. One truly bizarre story, "Wenlock Edge," ends with the main character watching college students making their way across campus. "On their way to deeds they didn't know they had in them."

So this isn't light fiction. One interview that our Alice read explained that Munro does not like fiction to be called "escape fiction"--she does not want to be read as an escape. Mission accomplished. No one would confuse her short stories with a good beach read. And don't go to these stories for a sense of redemption. Only a couple of them have seeds of hope planted in them, and even those come only after you've spent a good portion of the story expecting the worst to happen.

She draws very distinct characters and settings, and like Chekhov, who wrote that "One must not put a loaded rifle on the stage if no one is thinking of firing it," she gives subtle clues to careful readers (or re-readers) that are brought to fruition at the end of the story.

The stories in this book are set in Canada, mostly in the rural sort of area that Munro herself lives in, with one big exception. The last story is drawn from the true story of Sophia Kovalevsky, a Russian novelist and mathematician in the last part of the 19th century. This story has a Russian feel to it as well--lots of characters with multiple names, cold weather, long train rides, and lack of freedom of the female characters in comparison to the men are evocative of Anna Karenina. Sophia is recognized as a brilliant mathematician, but she finds it almost impossible to be hired by universities because she is a woman. We talked about the fact that the story is called "Too Much Happiness." And even more so the irony that this is also the title given to this collection.

Our discussions showed that people read for very individual reasons. Some read for that escape, some for inspiration, some for the enjoyment of a redemptive story, and some solely for the chance to read well-crafted work. One of the benefits of being in this book club is that we are pushed to try things we might not pick up otherwise, and we learn from the different reactions that each of us have. I think that Alice Munro may have won some admirers this month, but maybe not so many fans.

Why do you read?

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Mudbound: The Story of Us

The title says it all. Hillary Jordan's book Mudbound describes characters sucked into the ooze partly of their own making and partly of what has happened to them in their time, place and circumstance, just as we all are. This might sound like a complete downer, and it certainly has some terrible moments, but it is a good read. A compelling storyline and characters we can relate to (even when we wish we can't) make it a fairly quick yet meaningful book.

The book begins and ends with the burial scene of Pappy, the twisted, hateful patriarch of the white McAllan family. He is being buried in the rain, in the sodden, lonely fields of Mudbound, the farm that his son, Henry, has finally purchased after a lifetime of saving and dreaming. Not even to dust or ashes, Pappy is going to mud.

Henry is the stalwart, stoic eldest son who marries Laura later in life. Laura, a college-educated almost-spinster, is uprooted from her city life to become a farmwife. Henry's younger brother Jamie is a charmer who comes back from World War II with a hole in his heart.

The black Jackson family shares the farm as one of the tenants. Hap Jackson is determined to make more of his life than the fate of a sharecropper. His strong, intelligent wife Florence partners with him to make his dreams come true. Their hopes and dreams are also invested in their oldest son, Ronsel, another WWII vet. Ronsel's "got a shine to him"--he hopes for further education and a different life. He has trouble adjusting to the racism and Jim Crow laws of his Mississippi home after feeling freed from some of it in Europe during the war.

The interred Pappy is not the only one trapped by the land. Sharecroppers are fettered to the land and their landlords. Henry is sucked in to the land by his own "landsickness," a desire for the land that goes beyond what he feels for his wife and family. Ronsel is embedded in a community that can't see past his skin color, but he can't leave because he must help his family farm.

The good women of the Neland book club spent some time talking about the structure of the book. It is told from six different points of view, so the chapters go from character to character, giving us insight into each of their thoughts. Sometimes the voices were not as distinct as we might wish. Books like The Help and The Poisonwood Bible have been stronger in this respect. While we might not always be able to discern the actual voice of each character, we still see their perspectives distinctly. Many times we wish we didn't have to hear exactly what they were thinking. Jordan stays true to the time and place, and the racism of even the less racist characters angered us as we read, even as we could empathize with other aspects of the characters.

None of the characters is a true out-and-out hero, though there is still potential. Each are mired in their own natures--each a strange cocktail of their own experience, knowledge, hate, love, compassion, fear and pride. Some come close to heroism at different points, but can't really pull it off. Which would probably be true for about 99% of the human race.

The story rings true in other ways, too. One strand of the history of the U.S. is that of people looking for freedom and land, and using what power they have to realize that dream, even at the cost of marginalizing others.
Jordan's novel won the Bellwether Prize, which is a prize awarded to a previously unpublished novel that supports social change. There was a bit of discussion about whether or not Mudbound is a bit heavy-handed, but the consensus seemed to be that it really wasn't.
I definitely recommend it. And I will say, if I had any illusions that I might enjoy being a farmwife (which I really don't--I'm too lazy and enjoy city comforts), they are gone forever. If nothing else, the book might make you more thankful for your toilet and shower. Hopefully it will also raise your consciousness on other issues as well.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Dog Days: "The Art of Racing in the Rain"

This month the Fab 5 Book Club nosed their way through The Art of Racing in the Rain, by Garth Stein. Told from the perspective of Enzo, the loving dog of master Denny, the story moves through Enzo's life with Denny. From meeting Eve, Denny's future wife, the birth of their child, Eve's illness, and the horrible aftermath of the illness, Enzo gives his point of view, rich with wisdom gleaned from watching the Speed Channel, Weather Channel, and National Geographic Channel while Denny was away at work all day.

We all found the book appealing, not because the storyline is so great, but because we loved Enzo and the way he looked at the world. His loving and forgiving nature, his envy of short tongues and opposable thumbs, and his utter devotion to Denny. Even Nancy cried, and she is NOT a dog person.

Enzo says that he is like a person trapped in an isolation booth--he can't communicate anything he knows. And he knows so much. He knows the pain and pleasure of his family, he knows when illness has moved in, and he knows what mistakes they are all making. Enzo even has a spiritual side--he expects to be reincarnated, and he also recognizes the darkness that is in everyone, through his experience with an evil stuffed zebra.

Our dinner, heart-attack-on-a-plate in varying forms from Pietro's restaurant, even had a book connection--there are Italian racers in the book. Denny is a Formula One driver, and the book gives some detailed explanations about different aspects of racing. I had to wonder. So many books are written for a female audience, because women buy more fiction than men. (I've heard that's true, but have no data to back it up, so you'll just have to drink that Kool-Aid.) This book is about a man, a race car driver, and his beloved dog. So is this a men's book that women like to read? Or is it a women's book masquerading as a men's book? I suppose some less cynical people would think it could just be gender neutral. Marketing doesn't usually work that way. Any men out there who have read this one?

As usual, we drifted away from the book fairly quickly, making plans for a possible trip to Cincinnati where some of our members used to live. Apparently the city is rife with good restaurants, so it sounds like we will eat the entire time. Except for when we drive past Procter & Gamble. Not sure why, but this seems to be a major attraction. All I know about it is that half the people in Cincinnati seem to be paid to test one drug or another. The big question is: Do we all share one room with 2 double beds, get 2 rooms with 2 double beds, or get 1 room for 2 of us to share, and a separate room each for the other two? Cheapness is vying with a desire to sleep here. What would you recommend?

We would recommend this book. It's worth reading, and it's a quick one if you need a weekend take-along. The writing quality is patchy, definitely at it's best when recounting Enzo's ruminations about life and people. I personally enjoyed his theory that people keep dogs from evolving through breeding, and the penance we pay for this evil is that we have to turn a plastic bag inside out over our hands and pick up their fresh, er, leavings as they walked. Enzo's the best dog ever.